Brad Warner said that the thought process never goes anywhere. We can cogitate and cogitate but when it comes time to act, all that thinking will turn out to have been totally irrelevant. And if we follow a train of our own thoughts, we can’t expect them to lead us anywhere interesting, like a book would, because we’re just making them up. (of course, the author is just making up the book. Meaning and structure are relevant in fiction, require thought. Why should this not apply to our lives?)
This has caused me to think a lot. And every time I think I’ve got him foiled, think that there is a circumstance where musing or mulling imagining hypothesizing hypotheticalizing will get me somewhere, Brad turns out to be right after all. All those thoughts are just running me down. Yet thought is absolutely crucial to the practice of zazen, because understanding is its ultimate goal (I think). How can we understand something if we don’t think about it?
The key difference is in following your thoughts versus exploring your thoughts. A product of the practice of zazen would be a greater skill at exploring the currents of thought that come up naturally rather than damming them before they enter your mind and calling it a day, which is maybe how some people might interpret Brad’s comments on the issue. Memories intrude, my heart pounds, a schedule pops up, plans are wrought and re-wrought in my brain, all without producing any action in the best cases but a lot of times in fact impeding the action of the tasks immediately in front of me, which have nothing to do with the deluge in my mind that’s keeping me from doing them well.
So if I only have a limited amount of money, and several trips I want to go on this year, plus I’m sure many others that haven’t even occured to me yet, how do I decide which plane ticket to buy except by thinking about it? This is especially difficult because here “thinking” really just means elaborately daydreaming about what I’ll do in all of my potential destinations, even though I know that daydreams never come true, the reality always ends up forgotten, but I mean really forgotten, so that we don’t even have anything to compare our experiences with, if we’re lucky (and have been practicing zazen).